Here is what my gauge normally looks like going down the road.

Does yours look about the same Matt? With more redline I assume?
I tore into mine tonight. I did indeed find a T-stat in place. I can't tell if it is OEM, but is marked 78 deg C, just like the OEM replacement. Nothing obvious seemed to be wrong with it. As I'm prepping for track, a good flush and T-stat was in order anyways. I still have faith this fixed it though.
New OEM honda unit is on top, old unit is on bottom.

I will have to say it was kind of pain to change. The two T-stat bolts are unnecessarily hard to get to. I would have swore Hans designed it, but the housing and bolts were made out of metal, so that can't be. Matt, a *working* 10mm gear wrench would have done me wonders. Mine's a little gummed up though. As access is tight you can only rotate whatever is on either bolt a click or two at a time. Yours may be better or worse than mine since you have the TYPE-ARRR.
I'll report back tomorrow after I take it for a drive.