scottjohnson wrote:
Richard Casto wrote:
I am sure Dustin knows this, but for others watching the parade of "DirecTV dittos".... DirecTV does HD as well. I had an HD Tivo via DirecTV. And like TWC, DirecTV is far from perfect. However, I prefer DirecTV over cable.
TWC had HD DVR's out for a year (or more?) than the DirecTV DVR's.
When we got our HDTV we switched from satellite to cable to save a few bucks. At the time we would have needed to upgrade our dish, and our receiver at significant expense. After all that, I'd also need to have the local stations tuned in via the OTA antenna, and I *still* wouldn't have had any programming in any other rooms of the house (with cable, I get all the "analog" channels in any room for NO extra expense).
If I were starting from scratch today it might be different, but at the time, TWC actually had some value to offer. Especially since it appears that DirecTV is now going to offer the major networks in HD.
We're already on our 3rd DVR (one was a direct replacement, the 3rd an actual upgrade), and I haven't paid a dime for those changes.
Scott
Actually Scott, I "think" that DirecTV/Tivo had their HD DVR out first. Early/Mid 2004 with the TWC showing up very shortly after. The Tivo model has always been considered to be the best one available. However, when it first showed up it was VERY expensive. And that is why many went with the TWC model. Price has some down quite a bit recently (which is why I got mine about a year ago), but that same model that came out in 2004 is eventually going to have to be replaced due to technical issues that would take up lots of space to explain. Details on that swap has not been released, but most likely it will be free or with little cost to me.
Not to start a cable vs. sat thread, I understand your decision. I am puzzled about the cost to upgrade via DirecTV as usually that cost little to nothing if you are an established customer. I already had my house wired for sat and have had receivers since 1995, so I already have had the equipment and many free upgrades from DirecTV so a switch to cable for me personally just doesn't make any sense. I actually don't have the HD package from DirecTV as I am waiting for more content. But I use a small internal antenna with my HD Tivo and that gets all of the major networks stuff just fine. When DirecTV starts offering HD locals in this area and supports the next gen HD DVR, I may consider upgrading.
_________________
Richard Casto
1972 Porsche 914
2013 Honda Fit Sport
2015 Honda Fit EX
http://motorsport.zyyz.comMoney can't buy happiness, but somehow it's more comfortable to cry in a Porsche than a Kia.