Shane Eudy wrote:
I must be honest when I tell you that Highlands didn't really have any interest in continuing the Club Cub, at least for 2007.
Gwen Baake wrote:
I hope I’m not stepping off into a hornet nest...
My 1 cent (my opinion is not worth 2 cents as I am not even attending NCAC

)
(1) With it seeming that each club taking turns to host NCAC now, it seems to be up to each club as how they do this.
(2) So while something like Club Cup may be "expected", I don't think there is anything that says the host club "has" to do it. Until there is more of a generally agreed upon set of rules on "how to host NCAC" that all of the clubs agree to, I would expect future NCAC to be slightly different each year.
(3) Any type of competition between clubs is most likely (on average) to be won by the larger club on the assumption that they have a larger pool of talent to pull from. If rules are unfair then that needs to be addressed (I have no opinion on the rules used last year).
(4) I personaly think the #1 focus should be on the class winners and any type of "Club Cup" be a secondary concern. However I don't see ANYTHING wrong with doing something like the "Club Cup". It would be nice if it was scored the same way from year to year (see point 2 above about agreed upon rule and point 3 about fairness)
Shane Eudy wrote:
Stephen asked to have a meeting between the clubs' representatives rather than hash it out on the message boards. I hope that will still be possible.

_________________
Richard Casto
1972 Porsche 914
2013 Honda Fit Sport
2015 Honda Fit EX
http://motorsport.zyyz.comMoney can't buy happiness, but somehow it's more comfortable to cry in a Porsche than a Kia.