Jordan Normark wrote:
Size wise, from what I have read, you may be better off staying with a tread width that is closer to your rim width or even less. In the Miata community, they are faster with a slight stretch, a 225/45/15 on a 9" wheel is faster than the same tire on an 8" wheel. I don't know if that would hold true for your 50 series tire on the Mustang, but it's something to read into.
Jordan,
I want to learn as much about that aspect of street tires as possible, but there is a serious lack of information/test data out there -- just lots of opinions. Since I could only get 245/40-18 Rivals, I'm using those all around on stock width wheels, 8.5" front, 9.5" rear, and the rears are stretched a nice bit (you can't lay the tire/wheel face down as the wheel hits first, so I have to be careful changing them). The stock M3 front is this size, and the rear is a 265/40-18 (or with the 19" wheels, 245/35F, 265/35R).
I have planned to go to 275/35-18 all around after I wear these out (which is apparently going to take longer than I expected) as I feel like I could definitely use more tire in the rear at times even given how well the 245s are working. Compare that to Rich Wiese in the St Louis region with an E90 M3 F-stock car (consistently PAXing 1st or so) with Hoosiers: 295/30-18 front and 315/30 rears.

I can "feel" the nice taught rear tires in transitions it seems as there is no feeling of sidewall flex at all, just a nice, taught response. That is definitely one nice thing about a bit of stretch, the gain in sidewall spring rate. I guess I'll find out what happens when I make the switch to 275/35 all around...