jimpastorius wrote:
There was a paper written by a Russian scholar that states, the United States is going to split into seven territories. The very same thing that happen to Russia is repeating itself now in the United States.
And I can imagine a hypothetical Indian scholar saying that the United States will embrace its diversity and economic imbalance and come together in a stronger and purer democracy.
It all depends on your viewpoint. The Soviet Union broke apart because of vast differences between consituent entities, whereas the Indian democratic system was built to include even vaster differences.
Given that a war has already been fought once over whether to split or include, I would hope that we would follow the precedent of 140 years ago and go for acceptance and inclusion. Only without the violence this time.
I say that independent of my views on the tension and war between the USA and CSA. We'd be stupid to go back and repeat mistakes. I'm an optimist in this regard -- I personally believe that if it comes down to it, we'll have more in common with the Indian model than the former Soviet states model. The USA has dealt with vast economic and demographic differences in the past, and the only thing different now is better access to national media by the people who would rather split away from whatever minority they don't like this week. I'd like to think we're better than that these days.
As for topics like this, the one thing that distinguishes this thread in my mind is that despite the inflammatory title, discussion has been curteous, polite, and well informed. That's a debate, which can inform through opposing argument even if none of the people involved will ever change their position. That makes it not pointless, although whether it has a place in a car club forum is another subject entirely.
But the instant it turns personal, or arguments here move over into other threads, to me that's stepping out of bounds.
_________________
Martyn Wheeler
AXing Kit's '05 Mazda 3, #29 HStock
(when
The Gonzo Symphonic allows)