David Teague wrote:
Donnie, I have a feeling that somehow someway the TV Compaines will say that tvtorrents is violating a copyright and it will be gone, any thing that you can do for "free" over the internet seems to be under attack, I remeber there were pople in a tizzy about having episodes of the simpsons and south park on the web a few years ago, even though you could record them on your own tv.
David, you are exactly correct in that it is a copyright violation and that it will come under attack. I'd even go so far as to say it's Just Plain Wrong(tm) because of the simple fact that broadcast TV is only free because they can advertise to you, so folks distributing copies of shows like this with the ads already removed is just wrong. It can't lead to any outcome other than loss of free broadcast TV -or- the TV companies will find a way to stop it.
The problem with the latter, however, is that bittorrent file sharing is almost unstoppable. Given the basic premise of how it works, there is no central site to "shut down" to make it go away.
www.tvtorrents.tv is really just a handy place to find the .torrent file, which just tells you where to get started as far as downloading from some peer on the 'net. That could just as easily be shared via an email list, FTP site, web server (like we see now), or any other means of simple file dissemination. By itself it isn't illegal since there's really no file there...
Once you start the download, you are really just downloading from people who are "ahead" of you in their download (they don't even have to have the whole thing, they just have to have more than you have and you start downloading the chunks they have already gotten while they are still downloading from someone else who is "ahead" of them). Obviously ultimately someone has to have the whole thing, but stopping that original source before it gets it out to other sources will prove fairly impossible.
Personally, I don't think people should clip the ads before they upload. Then the TV industry is likely to get less annoyed by it. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that ultimately the only real solution may be for them to *allow* this kind of sharing as long as you *do* leave the ads. Anything else is piracy, which it already is, but would be a little easier to discern, anyway.
Well, *ultimately* perhaps we'll be able to get advertised versions of shows for free and then subscribe to the show without ads. I'd pay for several shows on TV right now, especially if I could get them "on demand" with no commercials.
That would be really nice if I could also integrate it into the MythTV system I was talking about earlier so it exists on one "server" in the house and I could watch at any time on any TV in the house.
--Donnie