Thanks very much for the input Dick.
I’m think I’m just fighting the fairly typical early Miata braking issues. The stock proportioning valve tends to be heavily biased towards the front and on top of that, the early Miatas tend to lock up the right front brake before anything else. With a stiff suspension, I think the situation is only compounded. I thought my braking performance was suffering due to the previous owner’s choice of rotors and pads but after putting a good set on the car a few weeks ago, I realized there are other issues. I believe the right-front lockup deal is mostly a weight bias issue and nobody I’ve seen has come up with a satisfactory solution.
I did recently service all my calipers (which are stock) and they seemed to be in great shape. I replaced all the seals and slider pins so I’m pretty sure there isn’t anything left to gain in performance there. The car does stop decently but just not as hard as I would like. Compared to ABS equipped Miatas I’ve ridden in, my braking performance definitely seems weak. Some of that may be an illusion since I wasn’t driving and the other Miatas had stock suspensions which caused a lot more nose dive. Scott Johnson recently drove the car and noted that the brakes seemed a little weak but I guess it could be hard to judge since it accelerates decently pushing braking points further back than most cars.
I’ve heard of a few people putting a Wilwood adjustable valve in place of the stock one but they wind up running it at full bias towards the rear and still don’t get enough rear braking. One relatively cheap and easy solution people have found is to use the stock proportioning valve from the ABS equipped Miatas as they tend to be a little bit more biased towards the rear. I’m hoping that I can find one from a junkyard over the winter. How this compares with the Wilwood solution, I have no idea. Other than being much easier to install… I may wind up trying both at some point.
If that doesn’t help, I will probably try the pad biasing as well. I’ve heard good things about the Hawk pads but couldn’t remember which pad was “stickier” than the other. If you’ve ever seen my car, you’d know I’m not too worried about brake dust.

I also have a set of big rear rotors from the new Miatas I could try as a possible solution but it will limit my wheel choice (no 13” ones, that’s for sure).
Unfortunately, most of my information was gleaned from various message boards. While I’ve always been careful to “know the source”, you never know what other factors are at work. That’s another reason I’d like to attend some bigger events next year-- hopefully I can meet some other fellow Miata drivers that are facing the same issues and chat with them.
Jim